Commodity
Colorants
A colorant is a substance valued for the color it imparts to something else. One technical distinction governs the entire trade. A pigment is insoluble: ground fine and suspended in a medium, it sits on or within a surface, which is how paints, inks, glaze oxides, and the colored grounds of cosmetics work. A dye is soluble and bonds to the substrate itself, which in practice means fiber, and requires a mordant to fix it and a bath to carry it. The two classes share almost no sources and almost none of the trades that handled them, and an entry about one is rarely about the other.
Because the value lies wholly in appearance, colorants have carried the highest prices per unit weight of nearly anything on this list, and the premium was always for a hue unobtainable another way. Tyrian purple is the limiting case. It was extracted from the glands of marine snails, chiefly <em>Murex brandaris</em>, at something like ten thousand shellfish to the gram — enough to dye the hem of a garment — and the discarded shells at Sidon built a mound some forty meters high. Diocletian's price edict of 301 CE valued a pound of the dye at 150,000 denarii, roughly three pounds of gold, and a pound of wool already dyed at a pound of gold. Tyre originated and dominated the trade; from the reign of Alexander Severus the production of purple silk was a state monopoly, and Roman sumptuary law reserved the color for magistrates, triumphing generals, and the emperor. In 1464 Paul II ordered scarlet to replace purple in Church vestments, which is a change of fashion that followed a change of supply.
The early modern colonial economies ran on two colorants. Cochineal, the dried bodies of an insect farmed almost entirely in Oaxaca by Indigenous producers, gave a red brighter and more saturated than anything in the Old World and roughly ten times the strength of the next best, and it became the second most valuable export of Mexico after silver. The Spanish authorities controlled access to it and kept the nature of its source secret; European naturalists established that it was an insect only in the eighteenth century. Indigo was the other, grown as a plantation crop in the Caribbean and in Bengal under conditions that produced their own revolts. In both cases the colorant was the commodity and the color was a monopoly.
Then the category underwent the sharpest substitution on the list. William Perkin's mauveine of 1856 was the first aniline dye; synthetic alizarin displaced madder, synthetic indigo ended the natural indigo trade within a generation, and synthetic dyes had largely replaced cochineal by the close of the nineteenth century. The consequence reached well beyond color: the synthetic dye business is the origin of the modern chemical industry and of the German combines that grew out of it, which is why this category and industrial chemicals appear together on the corpus entries about the dye alliances. A trade in cultivated insects and tropical crops became, in forty years, a trade in coal-tar derivatives made to order.
The boundaries all take the same form, separating the colorant from the thing colored and from the material it was won from. Lapis lazuli as a stone is a gem material; ground to ultramarine it is a colorant, and malachite and azurite divide the same way. Cinnabar as an ore is mercury; vermilion ground from it is here. Aniline and the other synthetic intermediates are industrial chemicals; the dye made from them is here. Dyed cloth is a textile, a glazed pot is ceramic, and a written sheet is papyrus, parchment, and paper — while the dye, the oxide, and the ink are all here. A preparation sold for the face is a cosmetic, which is what kohl is; the same pigment sold to a painter is a colorant. And several of these substances are lethal — lead white, Scheele's green, orpiment — so the rule is that a substance sold for its color is a colorant and one sold to kill is a poison. The category's date comes from the ocher-processing workshop at Blombos Cave around 100,000 years ago, with ocher carried to Pinnacle Point: ocher does nothing at all except look red, which makes this among the oldest commodities on the list whose value was entirely symbolic.