António, Prior of Crato: The Last Defender …
Years: 1580 - 1580
January
António, Prior of Crato: The Last Defender of Portuguese Independence (1580)
António, Prior of Crato (1531–1595), was the illegitimate grandson of King Manuel I and a claimant to the Portuguese throne during the succession crisis of 1580. Despite his weaker claim compared to Philip II of Spain and the Duchess of Braganza, he rallied popular support against Spanish rule, presenting himself as a second John I of Portugal, echoing the Crisis of 1385.
António’s Claim to the Throne
-
Son of Prince Louis (Duke of Beja) and Violante Gomes, António was illegitimate, which weakened his claim in the eyes of the Portuguese nobility.
-
His main rivals were:
- Philip II of Spain, the most powerful claimant, whose mother, Isabella of Portugal, was the eldest daughter of Manuel I.
- Catherine, Duchess of Braganza, a legitimate granddaughter of Manuel I.
-
After King Sebastian’s death at Alcácer Quibir (1578), António initially advanced his claim, but the succession was granted to Cardinal Henry, the elderly, childless uncle of Sebastian.
-
Upon Henry’s death in January 1580, the Cortes assembled in Almeirim, and a five-member regency juntaassumed power, preparing to select a new king.
António’s Popular Resistance Against Spanish Rule
- With Philip II of Spain pressing his claim, António appealed to national sentiment, portraying himself as Portugal’s last hope for independence.
- He argued that Portugal faced a situation similar to the 1383–1385 Crisis, when:
- The King of Castile had attempted to claim Portugal through blood descent.
- John I, Master of Aviz—also an illegitimate son of a Portuguese king—successfully defended Portugal at the Battle of Aljubarrota (1385).
- However, António lacked the support of the nobility, who largely favored Philip II, believing he would preserve their privileges.
- His main supporters came from:
- The lower clergy.
- Peasants and artisans.
- Those opposed to Spanish rule on nationalistic grounds.
Conclusion: The Last Hope for an Independent Portugal
Despite his historical comparisons to John I of Portugal, António, Prior of Crato, faced overwhelming opposition from the nobility and failed to prevent the Spanish succession. However, his resistance led to an armed conflict in the summer of 1580, making him the last Portuguese ruler to contest Spain’s annexation—a fight that would continue until Portugal regained independence in 1640.
