Flushing, now in Queens, New York, is…
February 1658 CE
Flushing, now in Queens, New York, is part of the Dutch colony of New Netherland.
Stuyvesant had formally banned the practice of all religions outside of the Dutch Reformed Church, the established church of the Netherlands, in the colony.
William Wickenden, a Baptist minister from Rhode Island, had in 1656 been arrested by Dutch colonial authorities, jailed, fined, and exiled for baptizing Christians in Flushing.
A group of Quakers from England had landed on June 1, 1657, at Long Island.
One of them, twenty-three-year-old Robert Hodgson, had preached to large crowds of people in New Amsterdam and consequently been arrested, imprisoned, and flogged on Stuyvesant’s orders.
Some sympathetic Dutch colonists had been able to get him released.
The preaching has continued with some positive response as well as some continued persecution.
Stuyvesant then made an ordinance, punishable by fine and imprisonment, against anyone found guilty of harboring Quakers.
Finally, on December 27, 1657 some of the English citizens of Flushing—none of whom are themselves Quakers—had written to Governor Peter Stuyvesant in protest.
They remind the governor that the colony's charter allows for freedom of conscience.
The document, called the Flushing Remonstrance, is the first instance in the American colonies of settlers petitioning for religious freedom.
Four who sign are arrested by order of Stuyvesant.
Two immediately recant, but the writer of the remonstrance, Edward Hart, and sheriff of Flushing Tobias Feake remain firm in their convictions.
Both men had been remanded to prison where they have survived in isolation on rations of bread and water for over a month.
After friends and family petition Stuyvesant on behalf of the elderly Hart, the clerk is released on penalty of banishment.
Feake holds out for a few more weeks, but eventually recants and is pardoned after being fined and banned from holding public office.
The town government of Flushing is removed and Dutch replacements are appointed by Stuyvesant.