Commodity
Emerald, ruby, and sapphire
This category holds the three precious colored stones. Ruby and sapphire are the same mineral, corundum, which is aluminum oxide; emerald is a different one, beryl, a beryllium aluminum silicate. In all three the host crystal is nearly worthless by itself and the entire value lies in impurity. Chromium substituting into corundum gives ruby its red; iron and titanium together give sapphire its blue; and chromium again, this time in beryl, gives emerald its green. The same contaminant produces red in one lattice and green in another because the crystal field around it differs, which is as neat a demonstration as the mineral world offers that in this trade the defect is the asset.
They belong together because they share one market structure, and it is unlike any other on this list. Production in each case concentrates in a handful of districts rather than being distributed. Each is subject to a treatment regime that covers effectively the whole supply rather than part of it. Each is sold on the strength of a laboratory certificate rather than on inspection. And historically all three were wanted by the same buyers — the Mughal, Ottoman, Persian and European courts — and today pass through the same dealers and the same auction rooms.
Corundum also has a second life having nothing to do with the first. At 9 on the Mohs scale it is the hardest natural material after diamond, and emery — impure granular corundum — was the grinding and polishing abrasive of antiquity and then of industry. Ruby and sapphire are therefore simultaneously among the most valuable substances on earth by the gram and among the cheapest by the tonne. Emerald has no such double identity; beryl is hard but not hard enough to grind anything.
The date here is emerald, and it is Egyptian. The workings at Mons Smaragdus in the Eastern Desert — the Sikait mines, popularly Cleopatra's — have a workers' camp securely dated by excavation to the third century BCE, with the mine running from about 330 to 30 BCE. The site's pharaonic attribution conflicts with its own archaeology and is best set aside. Sri Lankan sapphire was reaching Rome by about 100 BCE, and Mogok ruby enters the record from the fifteenth century; both are later. The geology behind all this is unobliging. Gem corundum needs aluminum-rich rock metamorphosed where almost no silicon is available, and emerald needs beryllium and chromium brought together, which ordinary geology keeps apart. Hence the short list of districts: Sri Lanka, upper Burma, Kashmir, Madagascar, northern Mozambique, and above all Colombia.
Colombia is the most concentrated position in the gem world. Muzo, Coscuez and Chivor are reckoned to supply something between seventy and ninety percent of the world emerald market, a dominance higher than most of the cartels that have ever been organized deliberately. It was founded on a seizure: Spain overpowered the Muzo from the middle of the sixteenth century, took roughly five decades to subdue them, compelled the people who had worked the deposits for centuries to go on working them for the crown, and held the mines from about 1600 until 1820. The demand this served was not principally European. The stones reached Europe and were then sought by the courts of India, Turkey and Persia, which is why the great carved and inscribed emeralds of the period are Mughal and Ottoman objects rather than Spanish ones.
The decisive modern event belongs to corundum, and it happened half a century before the equivalent in diamond. Edmond Frémy had made gem-quality synthetic ruby by 1877, and Auguste Verneuil's flame-fusion process — announced in 1902, published in 1904 — was the first commercially successful method for manufacturing a gemstone: alumina powder dropped through an oxyhydrogen flame above 2,000°C, building a single crystal on a rod withdrawn slowly from the heat. Output ran around a tonne a year by 1907 and two hundred tonnes by 1980. The market did not collapse; it divided. Synthetic corundum took the whole industrial field — abrasives, the jewel bearings timepieces run on, in heavy military demand during the Second World War, and eventually the first working laser, a rod of synthetic ruby — while natural ruby and sapphire kept the gem trade at an undiminished premium. Emerald is the control case: synthetic emerald exists and never captured a market, because there is no emerald equivalent of the watch bearing. What both outcomes produced is the certificate. Once a stone can be made, origin must be demonstrated rather than presumed, and since corundum is routinely heated, diffused or glass-filled and emerald is so often internally fractured that oiling or resin-filling is close to universal, disclosure is not an adjunct to this trade but the substance of it.
Burma is the standing political problem, and the instrument has changed twice. The Tom Lantos Block Burmese JADE Act of 29 July 2008 barred Burmese rubies and jadeite from the United States, including indirectly through third countries, and ran until 2016. After the 2021 coup the embargo returned by a different route: rather than legislate against a commodity, the Treasury designated Myanma Gems Enterprise — the ministry subdivision responsible for the country's gemstone activity and for the official selling emporiums — on 8 April 2021, having designated Myanmar Ruby Enterprise and others that February. Because that one entity sits astride all legal production, sanctioning a company accomplishes what a trade prohibition did; and because the chain is opaque, a buyer in Bangkok or Hong Kong cannot easily establish that a stone never passed through it. As to boundaries: ruby, sapphire, emerald, emery, and synthetic corundum in every form are here. Diamonds are their own category, and jade is deliberately not here — it is two minerals treated as one, with a continuous Chinese tradition reaching back some seven thousand years and a canonical movement as tribute into a court rather than trade between courts, and it stays with gem materials, which also covers the colored-stone trade considered generally. Bauxite and smelter-grade alumina belong to aluminium. A laser is a scientific instrument and the ruby rod inside it is here; a watch is a manufactured good and its jewel bearings are here. The date is c. 300 BCE, on the Egyptian emerald workings at Mons Smaragdus.