As the number of fires grows, so…
April 1741 CE
As the number of fires grows, so does the suspicion among whites that the fires are not accidents but planned arson.
When on April 6 a round of four fires breaks out, and a black man is spotted running away, a white man yells out, “A negro, a negro.”
The man’s cry is taken up quickly by a crowd and soon turns to, “The negroes are rising!”
They capture the running slave, Cuffee.
He is jailed, and within a few days, one hundred slaves are jailed.
Many people believe the fires are due to a conspiracy.
Initially tackling the problem of stolen goods and Hughson's tavern, the city council decides a to launch an investigation.
They turn it over to Horsmanden, who exercises great influence in interrogations and directing the grand jury's investigations.
Horsmanden puts a lot of pressure on Burton to talk about the fires.
Finally, Burton says the fires are a conspiracy between blacks and poor whites to burn down the town.
Horsmanden is pleased with her testimony but is convinced that Burton knows more about the conspiracy than she has told him.
He threatens to throw her in jail if she does not tell him more, so she testifies further.
There is rising fear about slaves and poor whites combining for insurrection.
Burton declares that the three members of the Geneva Club meet frequently at Hughson’s, that they had talked about burning the fort and town, and the Hughsons had agreed to help them.
Another person suspected in the fires is Peggy Kerry, a white woman who works as a prostitute to blacks; the room she lives in is paid for by Caesar, with whom she has a child.
Though Burton's testimony does not prove that any crime had been committed, the grand jury is so afraid that more fires will occur that they decide to believe her.
The city council also decides to pay a high reward to anybody who provides useful information about the conspiracy: one hundred pounds to a white person, fort-five pounds to a free black or native, and twenty pounds and freedom to a slave.
Such prices bring more testimony.