Arnold's fleet had met Allen's, which was still heading north, fifteen miles out on the lake,.
After an exchange of celebratory gunfire, Arnold had opened his stores to feed Allen's men, who had rowed one hundred miles (one hundred and sixty kilometers) in open boats without provisions.
Allen, believing he can seize and hold Fort Saint-Jean, had continued north, while Arnold sailed south.
Allen had arrived at Saint-Jean on May 19, where he was warned that British troops were approaching by a sympathetic Montreal merchant who had raced ahead of those troops on horseback.
Allen, after penning a message for the merchant to deliver to the citizens of Montreal, returns to Ticonderoga on May 21, leaving Saint-Jean just as the British forces arrived.
In their haste to escape the British, three men are left behind; one is captured, but the other two eventually return south by land.