Contrary to the usual picture of the …

Years: 1614 - 1614

Contrary to the usual picture of the Inquisition, ready to believe all and every confession of wrongdoing, Frías, the youngest judge in a panel of three assigned to the Basque witch trials at Logroño, is also skeptical about the whole thing, saying that he had found no substantive proof of witchcraft on his travels, in spite of the manifold confessions.

More than that, he questions the whole basis of the Basque witch trials.

Because of this disagreement on how to proceed, the matter has to be referred to the Inquisitor-General in Madrid.

The senior judges, Alonso Becerra y Holquin and Juan del Valle Alvarado, even go so far as to accuse their colleague of being "in league with the Devil".

Some of Frías' objections are remarkable, considering the atmosphere of the times, and are therefore worth quoting: The real question is: are we to believe that witchcraft occurred in a given situation simply because of what the witches claim?

No: it is clear that the witches are not to be believed, and the judges should not pass sentence on anyone, unless the case can be proven with external and objective evidence sufficient to convince everyone who hears it.

And who can accept the following: that a person can frequently fly through the air and travel a hundred leagues in an hour; that a woman can get through a space not big enough for a fly; that a person can make himself invisible; that he can be in a river or the open sea and not get wet; or that he can be in bed at the sabbath at the same time... and that a witch can turn herself into any shape she fancies, be it housefly or raven?

Indeed, these claims go beyond all human reason and may even pass the limits permitted by the Devil.

The Inquisitor-General appears to share his view that confession and accusation on their own are not enough.

For some time the central office of the Inquisition has been skeptical about claims of magic and witchcraft, and had only sanctioned the earlier burnings with considerable reluctance, and only because of the reported mood of panic from Logroño.

It rules in August 1614 that all of the trials pending at Logroño should be dismissed.

At the same time it issues new and more rigorous rules of evidence, that bring witch-burning in Spain to an end, long before the Protestant North.

Related Events

Filter results