San Eugenio had surrendered around 11:00 pm…
January 1780 CE
That duel had been passed by HMS Culloden and Prince George, which engage San Julián and compel her to surrender around 1:00 am.
The last ship to surrender is Monarca.
She nearly escapes, shooting away HMS Alcide's topmast, but is engaged in a running battle with the frigate HMS Apollo.
Apollo manages to keep up the unequal engagement until Rodney's flagship Sandwich comes upon the scene around 2:00 am.
Sandwich fires a broadside, unaware that Monarca has already hauled down her flag.
The British take six ships.
Four Spanish ships of the line and the fleet's two frigates escape, although sources are unclear if two of the Spanish ships were even present with the fleet at the time of the battle.
Lángara's report states that San Justo and San Genaro were not in his line of battle (although they are listed in Spanish records as part of his fleet).
Rodney's report states that San Justo escaped but was damaged in battle, and that San Genaro escaped without damage.
According to one account two of Lángara's ships (unspecified which two) had been dispatched to investigate other unidentified sails sometime before the action.
With the arrival of daylight, it is clear that the British fleet and their prize ships are dangerously close to a lee shore with an onshore breeze.
One of the prizes, San Julián, is recorded by Rodney as too badly damaged to save, and is driven ashore.
The fate of another prize, San Eugenio, is unclear.
Some sources report that she too was grounded, but others report that she was retaken by her crew and managed to reach Cadiz.
A Spanish history claims that the prize crews of both ships appealed to their Spanish captives for help escaping the lee shore.
The Spanish captains retake control of their ships, imprison the British crews, and sail to Cadiz.
The British report their casualties in the battle as thirty-two killed and one hundred and two wounded.
Spanish losses are twenty-five hundred captured, killed or wounded, with one ship destroyed
four ships captured.