Sonthonax, a fervent revolutionary and fierce supporter…
July 1797 CE
Although their goals are similar, there are several points of conflict.
The worst of these is over the return of the white planters who had fled Saint-Domingue at the start of the revolution.
To Sonthonax, they are potential counter-revolutionaries, to be assimilated, officially or not, with the ‘émigrés’ who had fled the French Revolution and are forbidden to return under pain of death.
To Toussaint, they are bearers of useful skills and knowledge, and he wants them back.
In summer 1797, Toussaint authorizes the return of Bayon de Libertat, the ex-overseer of Breda, with whom he has a lifelong relationship.
Sonthonax writes to Louverture threatening him with prosecution and ordering him to get Bayon off the territory.
Toussaint goes over his head and writes to the French Directoire directly for permission for Bayon to stay.
Only a few weeks later, he begins arranging for Sonthonax's return to France this summer.
Toussaint has several reasons to want to get rid of Sonthonax; officially he says that Sonthonax has tried to involve him in a plot to make Saint-Domingue independent, starting with a massacre of the whites of the island.
The accusation plays on Sonthonax's political radicalism and known hatred of the aristocratic white planters, but historians have varied as to how credible they consider it.