"Our Celestial Empire possesses all things in…
September 1793 CE
The mission is ultimately unsuccessful in its primary objectives, although the circumstances surrounding it provide ample opportunity for both British and Chinese parties not to feel totally disgruntled about the compromises and concessions they had made.
The failure of the primary objectives is not due to Macartney's refusal to kowtow in the presence of the Qianlong Emperor, as is sometimes believed.
It is also not a result of the Chinese reliance on tradition in dictating foreign policy, but rather a result of competing world views that are uncomprehending and to some extent incompatible.
After the conclusion of the embassy, Qianlong sends a letter to King George III, explaining in greater depth the reasons for his refusal to grant the several requests presented to the Chinese emperor by Macartney.
The requests had included a call for the relaxation of the restrictions on trade between Britain and China, the acquisition by Britain of "a small unfortified island near Chusan for the residence of British traders, storage of goods, and outfitting of ships"; and the establishment of a permanent British embassy in Beijing.
However, Qianlong's letter's continuing reference to all Europeans as "barbarians", his assumption of all nations of the earth as being subordinate to China, and his final words commanding King George III to "...Tremblingly obey and show no negligence!" uses the standard imperial sign off as if the king were a Chinese subject.
People
George Macartney, 1st Earl Macartney
View →
Henry Dundas, 1st Viscount Melville
View →
James Dinwiddie
View →
Jiaqing Emperor
View →
John Barrow, 1st Baronet
View →
Joseph Banks
View →
Qianlong Emperor
View →
Sir George Leonard Staunton
View →
Sir George Staunton, 2nd Baronet
View →
Thomas Hickey
View →
William Alexander
View →
William Grenville, 1st Baron Grenville
View →
William Pitt the Younger
View →