William II has continued his father's friendly…
1097 CE
William II has continued his father's friendly policy toward the Jews and allows converted Jews to return to Judaism, thus incurring the wrath of the Church.
He stages a disputation between Jews and Christians at one point hand jokingly remarks “If the Jews win I will convert.”
The Christians win, but the Jews are not penalized.
William II , less than two years after becoming king, had lost his father William I's advisor and confidant, the Italian-Norman Lanfranc, Archbishop of Canterbury.
After Lanfranc's death in 1089, the king had delayed appointing a new archbishop for many years, appropriating ecclesiastical revenues in the interim.
In panic, owing to serious illness in 1093, William had nominated as archbishop another Norman-Italian, Anselm—considered the greatest theologian of his generation—but this had led to a long period of animosity between Church and State, Anselm being a stronger supporter of the Gregorian reforms in the Church than Lanfranc.
William and Anselm disagree on a range of ecclesiastical issues.
The English clergy, beholden to the king for their preferments and livings, are unable to support Anselm publicly.
William in 1095 had called a council at Rockingham to bring Anselm to heel, but the archbishop has remained firm.
Anselm goes into exile in October, 1097, taking his case to the Pope.
The diplomatic and flexible Urban II, the new pope, is involved in a major conflict with the Holy Roman Emperor Henry IV, who supports an antipope.
Reluctant to make another enemy, Urban come to a concordat with William Rufus, whereby William recognizes Urban as pope, and Urban gives sanction to the Anglo-Norman ecclesiastical status quo.
Anselm remains in exile, and William is able to claim the revenues of the archbishop of Canterbury to the end of his reign.